Skip to content
The Garden ClassroomGrowing food, growing learners

Home › Compost & Soil

Composting Do's and Don'ts: What to Add, What to Avoid

November 14, 2026 · 2 min read

A quick reference for every composter: what you can and cannot put in a home compost pile, the habits that keep it working and the mistakes that cause smells, pests and slow compost.

Composting Do's and Don'ts: What to Add, What to Avoid
Photo: Ben_Kerckx / Pixabay

Composting is forgiving, but a few rules make the difference between rich compost and a smelly heap that attracts animals. Here is a quick reference you can print and stick on the fridge.

What you can and cannot compost

Do compostDon't compost
Fruit and vegetable scrapsMeat, fish and bones
Coffee grounds and filters, tea leavesDairy products
EggshellsFats, grease and cooking oil
Dry leaves, straw, wood chipsPet waste and used cat litter
Grass clippings (not treated with herbicide)Diseased or pest-infested plants
Shredded newspaper and plain cardboardWeeds that have gone to seed
Garden trimmings and spent plantsCoal or charcoal ash
Nut shells, hair and fur, cotton and wool ragsGlossy or coated paper, plastics, "compostable" packaging meant for industrial facilities

The do's

  • Do balance greens and browns. Roughly two to three parts dry browns to one part moist greens by volume keeps the pile working.
  • Do chop large pieces. Smaller pieces break down much faster.
  • Do bury food scraps and cover them with browns to stop flies and smells.
  • Do keep it moist, about as damp as a wrung-out sponge.
  • Do turn it every week or two to add air and speed things up.
  • Do keep a stock of browns, such as a bag of autumn leaves, next to the bin.
  • Do use finished compost in beds, pots and on the lawn.

The don'ts

  • Don't add only kitchen scraps. Without browns, the pile turns wet, airless and smelly.
  • Don't let it dry out. A dry pile stops working.
  • Don't pack it down. Compacted material loses the air microbes need.
  • Don't add herbicide-treated grass or plants. Some herbicides survive composting and can damage garden plants later.
  • Don't put the bin on concrete if you can avoid it: soil contact helps.
  • Don't use unfinished compost around seedlings. Let it cure until it is dark, crumbly and earthy-smelling.

Gray areas

  • Citrus peels and onions: fine in an outdoor pile in moderation; limit them in a worm bin.
  • Bread and pasta: can attract animals; bury them deep or use bokashi.
  • Wood ash: small amounts of ash from untreated wood are fine; it is alkaline, so go easy.
  • Sawdust: only from untreated wood, and mix it in, as it clumps.

Cooked food, meat and dairy have a place too: bokashi can take them. For the full setup, see our guide to starting composting at home.

Questions

What should you never put in compost?

Meat, fish, bones, dairy, fats and oils, pet waste, diseased plants, weeds with seeds, herbicide-treated trimmings and coal or charcoal ash.

Can you compost eggshells?

Yes. Crush them first so they break down faster.

Can you compost paper towels?

Plain paper towels and napkins without grease or cleaning chemicals can go in as browns.

Why is my compost not breaking down?

Usually it is too dry, has too many browns or needs air. Add water and greens and turn it.

Sources

  1. Iowa State University Extension: The Do's and Don'ts of Composting
  2. University of Georgia CAES: Do's and don'ts of composting
  3. US EPA: Composting at Home